diff --git a/KfChatDotNetBot/Commands/KasinoGambaCommands.cs b/KfChatDotNetBot/Commands/KasinoGambaCommands.cs
index 5556c70..3a43648 100644
--- a/KfChatDotNetBot/Commands/KasinoGambaCommands.cs
+++ b/KfChatDotNetBot/Commands/KasinoGambaCommands.cs
@@ -532,7 +532,7 @@ public class Planes : ICommand
                 }
                 else if (row == 7) //water/carrier row
                 {
-                    if ((counter + column) % carrierCount == 0) output += Carrier;
+                    if (((fullCounter - 3) + column) % carrierCount == 0) output += Carrier;
                     else output += Water;
                 }
                 else //this leaves rows 0-5 and columns 0-24, exactly what we need for the board